AP english final paper---- Irma Martinez Mr. Golembeski AP English June 3, 2007 A Research Paper on the Handmaid's Tale Margaret Atwood's novel "the Handmaid's Tale" is a representation of the egoistical measures taken by
men to restrict the power gains of women throughout the centuries. As time goes by the power of women augments into greater freedoms. It is through this loss of neccessity that men felt the need to strip women of all choice by creating Gilead. Gilead is a turn of the century enclosure morphed by antiquated morals of the bible, thought to salvage the people of the United States. Whom had exhausted all aspects of society by becoming too self-indulgent. Yet this new government is still a woman's world, simply "policed" by men, they failed to realize that a woman's greatest power is her femininity and ability to reproduce. It is this macho need for domineerance that drove men to annihilate all free will from the opposite sex. The
commander clearly stated, "The main problem was with the men. There was nothing for them anymore . . . I’m not talking about sex, he says. That was part of it, the sex was too easy . . . You know what they were complaining about the most? Inability to feel. Men were turning off on sex, even." (Atwood ). This need for the regainment of power drove the government, men in particular, to strip women of the one thing they now had; full hegemony over their sexuality. After decades of fighting for women's rights and liberations, they were unbound to men and the authority to choose their own lifestyles. Women became free as individuals and began to rebel against all standard morals, "girls, felt-skirted as I knew from pictures, later in mini skirts, then pants, then one earring, spiky green-streaked hair." (Atwood 3). Victoria Glendinning affirms that "[Atwood] is justly claimed by the feminists, in that power struggles for a woman tend to be with men." (Glendinning 41). Aunt Lydia ingrains into all handmaids that they should be thankful because " "There is more than one kind of freedom...Freedom to and freedom from. In the days of anarchy, it was freedom to. Now [they] are being given freedom from. Don't underrate it." (Atwood 24). This brainwashing of the Handmaids was neccessary to make them believe that there was a cause for their containment. As Elaine Kendall assures, "virtually all civil rights gained by women...during the last century have been rescinded. (Kendall 12).The lack of virile authority, led men to seek a way in which they could once again regain prestige in the world. Throughout the entire novel there are numerous sexual inuendos that exhibit the power women reserve,
even after the new government arrangements. In defiance to the power struggle between sexes, homosexual emerged in exponential numbers; in such relationships there is a balance of power, because women accept equality. Moira is the perfect example of sexual bravado, she refused to give in to the "price of obedience...--the death of the senses, the death of the spirit" (Johnson 2). Moira evades losing her sexual activities, and holds strong to the lifestyle of the women at the time; "Moira had power...she was now a loose woman" (Atwood 133). Although Offred was condemned to this society she still found ways to use her body for desire and personal enjoyment. Such as that she had on the soldiers as "they touch with their eyes instead, and [she] move her hips a little...it's like teasing...a dog with a bone held out of reach" (end of chpt 4). This provocativeness clenches men into submission of the opposite sex. Even though this society was created to purify the country, men still were in need of infatuation. "Nature demands variety, for men" (Atwood 37). Maynard reports that "it's a society-formed in reaction to one form of corruption-that begins corrupting its own rules"; no man is perfect and all have a need to rebel (Maynard ). The hunger for sex, the drive for fulfillment surpasses the discipline in Gilead. This policing of women, was intended to deliver them from harms way. The struggles women must
ovecome in the novel "will no doubt [make it] be labeled a "feminist 1984" (Johnson 2). Offred tells her tale as she recounts her past, revealing that women were made objects of dependence. All her monitary possessions were t transfered under her husband; she was fired from work, for being a woman of course. Women were made to believe that they were responsible for the anguish they were living in; "Janine, telling about how she got gang- raped at fourteen and had an abortion. Her fault, her fault, her fault [they] chant in unision" (Atwood 13). Of course, some aspect of society will always be worse off than others. Handmaids were this part of society and the commander confessed this flaw, "Better never means better for everyone, he says. It always means worse for some." (Atwood 211). Handmaid's were never really meant to be protected for anything more than their ability to reproduced, they were women yes, but they were condemned to carry the weight of survival on their shoulders. Because of this they had a need to be protected, and who better to complete the job then the useless men who put them there in the first place. Consequently, the desperation of a doomed society for survival, led men to classify the female sex as
women and unwomen. The women were divided into positions according to their abilities; what they can offer to the structure. There were wives, marthas, handmaids, aunts and daughters; all fulfilling their assigned duties. Those that failed to be of any use to the government were sent off to the colonies to die a slow and painful death. They were women who rebeled, who refused to give in, refused to give up; they had their tubes tied in protest, they would not becoming birthing machines. Those who were too old, or were found to be infertile were sent to the colonies as well. These women were thought of as a drain on a fallen society. This place, "it's a vision of hell [for women]... but [Atwood] calls the place the Republic of Gilead" (Maynard). However, if subjected to the loss of power, they gained the ability to live. But their survival depended on their ability to create life; "Give me children, or else I die", a straightforward statement. (Atwood 88). The handmaids that were able to give birth to a living child within the three years they were given were promised a future life without ever being transfered to the colonies, even if the failed to have another child. This promise of some sort of sanctity, led many to bend the rules in order to empregnant themselves. Most understood that it was the men who failed to be fertile, it was the men who weren't able to procreate. Yet, blame was placed on the women. So, other measure were taken, on most occasions with the help of the wife a handmaid was found another source of semen. A precaution, while at the same time a sin. One might even distinguish a similarity in the red dress of the handmaid, to the fiery red of the A worn by Hester Prinn. They were seen as whores, "Agreed to it right away, really she didn't care, anything with two legs and a good you-know-what was fine with her", willing to do anything to get pregnant. (Atwood 215). Society understands the commanders are sterile, " 'The door is locked. No one will come in. They'll never know it isn't his.' " (Atwood ). Even the doctor was willing to risk his life when he offered help to Offred, this is her chance to break fromroutine, but the act is too risky, and though thoughts of suicide frequently pass through her mind she refuses totake the chance and face death. The importance of giving birth to a child that will survivelingers so heavily on every member of society. This new society failed to strip women of all their power, they failed to see that it remains a woman's world,
everything depends on them. Handmaid's are essential to the survival of a population that has for decades failed to provide children to keep the country alive. Ellen Kendall warns that "The Handmaid's Tale could be the ultimate doomsday book" (Kendall 1). The lack of family values, leads to a sense throughout the entire novel of moral majority. It is the woman, and only she that carrys the joy of life, "[the woman] shall be saved by childbearing" ( Atwood 221). Men aren't allowed any power but to protect. They may head the government and hold "control" over the women, but this amounts to nothing. The wife is the one who runs things at home. Men are restrained, all but the commanders, to live their life in the perversion of desperate desire for a woman touch. Offred mother had fought her entire life to create a society in which women were the undenyable rulers. McCarthy points out the irony found in the book as Offred thinks to herself in regard to her absurd mother, " 'you wanted a woman's culture. Well now there is one.' The wrong kind, of course" (McCarthy 1). It may be the wrong kind, in a sense that women aren't fully aware of their true hidden power, they fail to recognize their greatest asset and weapon. Likewise, there is weight in the small rebellions some women of Gilead accomplished in order to deny
submission. For example there is the "Femaleroad" which smuggled protestors into Canada. Much like the underground railroad during the civil war, all participants faced ultimate death if they were caught. After Moira was found, she never really knew what happened to the innocent Quakers that aided her, but she has an idea. Offred even becomes aware of the secret group through Ofglen wiht the words "May Day" to identify each other. This power to realize the flaws in the government foreshadows the eventual failure that will befall it. Another form of rebellion towards this inept society is that of suicide by the handmaids. Finding a woman that is able to have children, children that will survive is so hard at this time. It is the ultimate Thomas Hardy move to commit suicide as a handmaid. Offred often thinks of all the possible ways in which she could kill herself using the few materials in the room. Men failed once again to admit the susceptibility they have for the opposite sex; they cannot refuse them. This is clearly seen during the private meetings the commander had with Offred. As the number of meetings increase, so does her confidence and attitude with the commander. She begins to ask him for things, that he willingfully provides, like the handlotian, the magazines. Then her conduct, her voice changes, she takes more charge of the situation. She even lectures him when he almost gave them away at the first ceremony after their encounters. She feels herself taking more power from him, and enjoys it. The entire novel is a grand fairytale about the loss of power of women; a power taken by men. Yet, truly, this is a false idea as Glendinning assures, " to suggest (mistakenly) that Atwood is getting preachy herself", that would definately be wrong. (39). Throughout the book there is a lot of hidden meaning underlying a single message. Women cannot be deprived of prerogative, they thrive on accomplishments and achievements. It will always be a woman's world. Margaret Atwood's predictions on the downfall of society are fairly realistic. It's a vision of hell, a hell in
which women fall victim to the hubris of men. Women have become too powerful as independent figures in today's world to allow men to strip them of their freedom's. She was correct in that there will be a women's world, but one in which women have the say, not men. A ficticious novel, a prediction that will fail to come true, because the feminine world of today has become to powerful for any man to take control. Nolite te bastardes carborundorum.
works cited BookRags.2006.BookRags Books Notes. 31 May 2007.
Glendinning, Victoria. "Lady Oracle." Saturday Night 101.1 (1986): 39-41. Johnson, Joyce. "Margaret Atwood's Brave New World" The Washington Post 2 Feb. 1986: 1-2. Kendall, Elaine. "The Handmaid's Tale" Los Angeles Times Book Review 9 Feb. 1986:1, 12. Lehmann-Haupt Christopher. "The Handmaid's Tale" New York Times 27 Jan. 1986:C24. Maynard, Joyce. |